Is a Private Mortgage Better Than One from a Bank?

Over the past couple of years, the cost of living in Canada has continued to increase alongside interest rates, putting many aspiring homebuyers in a particularly unfavourable situation. As traditional lenders like the big banks steadily increased their lending criteria, many Canadians found it increasingly more difficult to qualify for the funding they needed — leading to an increase in the popularity of private lenders. Both traditional and private mortgages have their pros and cons, and understanding these nuances can significantly impact your decision-making process when it comes to purchasing a home. In this guide, we will take a closer look at these differences, and explore why some homebuyers opt for private mortgages over traditional bank loans.

Private Mortgages vs. Bank Mortgages

While there are a number of policy and protocol differences between private and bank mortgages, the fundamental difference between them is their source of funding.

Private Mortgages:

What is a private lender mortgage? Private mortgages occur when individuals, or private entities, loan money directly to borrowers. These lenders can be private investment firms, for instance, but can also take the form of family members or friends that may be willing to offer a loan. Private mortgages are most common amongst borrowers that are unable to secure financing through traditional banks, be it due to poor credit history, unconventional income sources, or other unique factors.

Bank Mortgages:

Bank mortgages, on the other hand, are loans provided by financial institutions such as banks, credit unions, or mortgage companies. These loans often follow a much more rigorous application process, that is standardized amongst all borrowers. Banks are furthermore subject to a greater number of regulatory guidelines that are set out by government agencies — leading to a lack of flexibility on approval criteria. If you have a good credit score and a stable income, bank mortgages will typically offer you competitive interest rates and more favourable terms than their private counterparts.

Explore further

Can I afford a million-dollar home? Open vs. Closed Mortgage: What’s the Difference? The New Stress Test Is In Effect: How to Still Qualify for a Mortgage House Bidding Wars in Canada: What You Need to Know

The Pros and Cons of Private Mortgage Lenders

Pros of Private Mortgage Lenders:

• Flexibility: Compared to bank mortgages, private mortgages often offer more flexible in loan approval criteria. This allows borrowers who may not meet the traditional mortgage criteria to qualify for the financing they need.
• Quick Approval: Private mortgage lenders often have shorter approval processes compared to banks, enabling borrowers to expedite the home-buying process.
• Customized Terms: Private lenders can be more prepared to negotiate terms such as interest rates, repayment schedules, and collateral requirements based on your individual circumstances.

Cons of Private Mortgage Lenders:

• Higher Interest Rates: Private mortgages usually have higher interest rates than bank mortgages, due to the increased risk undertaken by the lender.
• Limited Protections: You may be subject to fewer legal protections when dealing with private mortgage lenders, as these transactions are often less regulated than bank mortgages.
• Potential for Strained Relationships: In cases where the lender is a friend or family member, there is a risk that your relationship may be strained — especially if payment issues or disputes arise.

Why Some Homebuyers Prefer Private Mortgages over Traditional Bank Loans

Despite the potential drawbacks, many homebuyers opt for private mortgages due to certain advantages that may better align with their unique circumstances and preferences.

• Accessibility: Private mortgages provide an alternative financing option for borrowers who may not meet the stringent criteria of traditional banks , be it due to income, credit score, or property type.
• Speed and Efficiency: Compared to traditional mortgages, private mortgage transactions can usually be processed more quickly, allowing homebuyers to capitalize on time-sensitive opportunities to snag their dream home.
• Personal Relationships: Borrowers who value personal relationships and trust may prefer obtaining financing from private lenders, particularly if the lender is a family member or close acquaintance. This dynamic can lead to more flexible terms and a smoother borrowing experience.

Ultimately, the decision between a private mortgage and a bank mortgage depends on your financial situation, personal risk tolerance, and preferences. While private mortgages offer flexibility and accessibility, they come with inherent risks and may not be suitable for everyone. Conversely, bank mortgages provide stability and regulatory protections but may be less accessible to certain borrowers. Still unsure? You may want to enlist the help of a Clover Mortgage broker. By weighing the pros and cons of each option and considering your individual needs, our expert team can help you make informed choices that align with your homeownership goals. Contact us to schedule your free consultation today!

FAQ

Is a private mortgage better than a bank?

Unfortunately, when it comes to comparing private and bank mortgages, there is no one-size-fits-all answer. Finding the ideal mortgage type for you, in terms of lender vs bank, will depend heavily on your personal and financial circumstances.

What are the disadvantages of a private mortgage lender?

When looking at the pros and cons of private mortgage lenders, there are a few notable downsides that are important to consider. When choosing private mortgage lenders vs banks (in Canada), here are some potential cons to consider:

1. Higher Interest Rates: Private mortgages usually have higher interest rates than bank mortgages, due to the increased risk undertaken by the lender.
2. Limited Protections: You may be subject to fewer legal protections when dealing with private mortgage lenders, as these transactions are often less regulated than bank mortgages.
3. Potential for Strained Relationships: In cases where the lender is a friend or family member, there is a risk that your relationship may be strained — especially if payment issues or disputes arise.

Are private mortgages more expensive?

Private mortgages often come with higher interest rates compared to traditional bank mortgages, which can make them more expensive over the life of the loan.